How Do I Know If Hail Damage on My Roof Is Serious Enough to File an Insurance Claim?

Table of Contents

TL;DR: How Do I Know If Hail Damage on My Roof Is Serious Enough to File an Insurance Claim?

Hail damage is serious enough to file an insurance claim when shingles show bruising, cracking, granule loss, or when leaks develop after a storm. In Rochester, MN, professional inspection is the most reliable way to determine whether damage is cosmetic or structurally significant.
Hail damage on roof showing bruising and granule loss

Why Hail Damage Is Common in Rochester, MN

Hail storms are a regular occurrence in Southeast Minnesota. Even small hailstones can weaken asphalt shingles, while larger hail can crack or fracture roofing materials.

The challenge for homeowners is that hail damage is not always obvious from the ground. What appears minor may compromise the roof’s long term performance.

What Hail Damage Actually Looks Like

Hail damage is not always dramatic. Instead of missing shingles, it often appears as:

  • Dark bruised spots on shingles
  • Soft impact marks that feel spongy
  • Granule loss exposing the underlying mat
  • Cracks radiating from impact points
  • Dented flashing or metal vents

These bruises weaken the shingle’s protective layer and may shorten the roof’s lifespan.

Cosmetic vs Functional Damage

Not all hail damage requires a full roof replacement. The key distinction is whether the damage affects function.

Cosmetic damage may involve minor granule scuffing without compromising waterproofing.

Functional damage includes:

  • Shingle fractures
  • Exposed fiberglass mat
  • Lifted or loosened shingles
  • Leaks following the storm

Functional damage typically warrants further action and may justify filing a claim.

Interior Warning Signs After a Hail Storm

Sometimes the first clue of serious hail damage appears inside the home.

Watch for:

  • Ceiling stains
  • Dripping water during rain
  • Peeling paint near roof lines
  • Attic moisture

If interior signs develop after a storm in Rochester, a roof inspection should be scheduled immediately.

When Filing an Insurance Claim Makes Sense

Homeowners may consider filing a claim when:

  • A recent hail storm affected the area
  • Multiple shingles show impact bruising
  • There is visible cracking or splitting
  • Water intrusion occurs
  • Neighbors are filing similar claims

Insurance typically covers sudden storm damage but does not cover normal aging or neglected maintenance.

Why a Professional Inspection Is Critical

It is difficult to assess hail damage accurately without walking the roof. A professional inspection can:

  • Identify hidden impact damage
  • Distinguish cosmetic from structural damage
  • Document findings clearly
  • Provide photos for insurance documentation

In Rochester, working with a local roofing contractor familiar with hail patterns improves accuracy.

Understanding Your Insurance Policy

Coverage depends on policy type.

Replacement cost policies generally provide broader protection. Actual cash value policies account for depreciation based on roof age.

Reviewing your deductible and coverage type helps determine whether filing a claim is financially practical.

Avoiding Common Mistakes After a Storm

After a hail event, homeowners should avoid:

  • Waiting too long to schedule an inspection
  • Assuming damage is minor without evaluation
  • Signing agreements without understanding scope
  • Ignoring small interior stains

Timely action helps prevent further deterioration.

Above All Roofing provides roof inspections for homeowners, churches, and commercial properties throughout Rochester, MN. The goal is to provide clear documentation so property owners can make informed decisions about insurance claims and repairs.

Table of Contents

LATEST POST

Above All roofing black background logo

Experience Quality Roofing with Above All Roofing of Rochester

Join countless satisfied homeowners in Rochester. Trust our locally owned company for top-notch roofing services that stand the test of time

Scroll to Top

Request Service

Please fill out the form below to request your free evaluation and estimate. Someone from our team will be in touch with you shortly. We look forward to working with you.